|
Happy Saturday, you oxygen-dependent meathead. Tomorrow my Minnesota Vikings and the San Francisco 49ers are scheduled to collide in Mexico City, roughly 7,350 feet above sea level, where the air is thin, the hits are enormous, and the internet has apparently issued 40,000 honorary PhDs in exercise physiology to any GooRoo with an iphone and an IG account. I found out by making the mistake of scrolling Instagram... ..sweet merciful mitochondria. Every third person has THE definitive altitude protocol. Half the comments are written with the certainty of a Nobel laureate. The other half sound like somebody inhaled a pre-workout scoop through a CPAP machine and started screaming about red blood cells in the ring light. The consensus among the newly minted armchair physiologists? San Francisco has this part figured out. They spent the week in Colorado Springs getting used to elevation. The Vikings? Arrived today -- Saturday to smash helmets Sunday and fly home Monday. Except Minnesota has a little trick hiding in the training facility: a simulated-altitude chamber installed roughly five weeks ago, with more than 450 sessions across the roster and the simulated elevation reportedly progressing from about 9,000 to 12,000 feet (NFL, 2026). So now we have two very different experiments conducted on enormously expensive human meat sticks. San Francisco: live at elevation for a week. Minnesota: sample the hypoxic suffering in a chamber, sleep at home, and parachute into Mexico City late. Which one wins? Ohhhh, we are going WAY down the oxygen nerd chute. Grab your a$$ cheeks with both hands Bro! First, the air did not forget how to contain oxygen At actual altitude, the fraction of oxygen in ambient air is still about 20.9%. The problem is that barometric pressure drops, so the partial pressure of that oxygen drops with it. Each breath has less oxygen pressure available to drive O₂ from the alveoli into your blood. You can write the problem on a napkin using the simplified alveolar gas equation that I am sure you all have memorized, yes? PAO₂ ≈ FIO₂ × (PB − 47) − (PaCO₂ / R) Where PB is barometric pressure, 47 mmHg accounts for water vapor in warmed, humidified air, PaCO₂ is arterial carbon dioxide pressure, and R is the respiratory exchange ratio (often approximated as 0.8). At sea level, inspired PO₂ is about 150 mmHg. Around Mexico City's elevation, using an illustrative barometric pressure of 580 mmHg, inspired PO₂ is only about 112 mmHg. Plug in plausible CO₂ values and your alveolar oxygen pressure can land roughly in the 60--70 mmHg neighborhood instead of around 100 at sea level. Those are back-of-the-envelope values, not measurements of an NFL player's arterial blood. But they show why the oxygen gradient gets mugged in broad daylight, in short, there is much less pressure pushing oxygen in. Your peripheral chemoreceptors notice the drop. Oh crap! Ventilation (aka breathing rate) goes up. Blowing off more CO₂ helps defend alveolar oxygen pressure, but also can push blood toward respiratory alkalosis. Over the following days, the kidneys can excrete more bicarbonate, making sustained increased ventilation easier. Voilà, you are not huffing and puffing after going up flights of stairs like you just started a 2 pack a day Marbo Red cigs with no filter. That is one piece of acclimatization. Another involves plasma-volume changes; with sufficient exposure over longer periods, erythropoietic responses may contribute, AKA your body notices that oxygen is in tighter demand than beer at a Vikings tail gate party . The timing, magnitude, and performance payoff depend heavily on the actual hypoxic dose. What does all this mumbo jumbo nerd speak mean so far? No, your body does not hear "Colorado Springs" and instantly print a fresh pallet of red blood cells like a malfunctioning FedEx warehouse. Why a 300-pound defensive lineman should care about his aerobic system "But Dr Mike, football isn't a bike race, it is a hardcore anaerobic event?" Correct. Congratulations Brosefus, however there is a catch. It is true that an NFL play might last only seconds. High-force actions rely heavily on phosphocreatine and anaerobic metabolism; but that phosphocreatine has to be resynthesized between violent little bursts, and it is your aerobic (oxygen loving) metabolism does a lot of the repayment work. Picture Dallas Turner detonating out of his stance, wrestling a refrigerator with legs, then getting a short break before doing it again. And again. And yet again. For four quarters. Now lower the oxygen availability and ask the aerobic system to help refill the phosphocreatine tank between collisions. That is why altitude can matter even in a sport that isn't remotely a continuous endurance event. The size of the effect for actual NFL game performance? We do not have a clean number. We do have a warning shot from endurance athletes. Schuler and colleagues (2007) tested eight elite cyclists at about 7,700 feet (2,340 m). On day one, VO₂max fell 12.8%, while time to exhaustion dropped a whopping 25.8%. Performance improved over the next two weeks though. Before you start announcing a 25.8% collapse in fourth-quarter pass rushing, not so fast. Eight elite cyclists doing an endurance test are not NFL linemen rotating through short plays. The study demonstrates the size of a possible acute aerobic hit, not a football-specific prediction. It also reminds us that altitude stress is a moving target. The initial oxygen problem is immediate; sleep disturbances and symptoms may develop over subsequent days. The 49ers are buying acclimatization. The Vikings are buying a normal week. San Francisco's Colorado Springs plan has an obvious physiological argument: repeated hours living and sleeping at elevation provide a continuous stimulus. Ventilation can adjust, acid--base compensation can start, and the environment becomes less novel. One week is not a magical complete-acclimatization ticket, though. Bigger changes often take several weeks. The dose matters, and so does what the adaptation costs you along the way. Meanwhile, Minnesota's chamber exposes players to simulated altitude while they remain in a familiar training and recovery environment. The team reports more than 450 sessions across the roster. That's meaningful effort, but please do not divide by some imaginary number and announce that every player got a specific dose. We do not know each player's total exposure, precise session protocols, or individual response (NFL, 2026). The difference between a chamber and a mountain also matters. Real altitude is hypobaric hypoxia: lower ambient pressure. Many altitude chambers produce normobaric hypoxia by reducing the oxygen fraction at normal pressure. Both can lower inspired oxygen pressure, but they are not interchangeable experimental conditions in every respect. Most importantly, doing exercise while hypoxic can acutely make that exercise harder. That does not mean the chamber is useless. The point may be the adaptations or familiarity created by repeated exposures, not posting an impressive workout while oxygen-deprived. If you are a player, finding out how much you are sucking air on rep 1 in the game is not ideal. Doing some exercise in a hypoxic environment can help you mentally prepare as you have an idea of how much it may suck large moose ballZ. Think of it as two different invoices from the physiology department. San Francisco is paying in continuous exposure, plus potential disruptions to sleep and routine. Minnesota is paying in intermittent chamber sessions while trying to keep the normal-week recovery perks. Neither invoice comes with a guaranteed win on Sunday. What About the Research Though? Now we get to the research that makes a meathead's little mitochondria tingle. Brocherie et al. (2017) pooled nine controlled studies involving 202 athletes. Repeated-sprint training in hypoxia produced a modest improvement in mean repeated-sprint performance, with an effect size of 0.46 sitting right on the edge of statistical significance. Best-sprint performance and VO₂max? No reliable advantage. A later multilevel meta-analysis of 18 trials reported a moderate overall benefit, especially for repeated-sprint ability (Han & Liu, 2025). Then a November 2026 analysis crashed the party with 10 studies and 216 unique athletes: a small statistically significant overall effect, Hedges' g = 0.31 (95% CI 0.12 to 0.50). Repeated-sprint time and sprint decrement improved; the advantage for power or work output was uncertain. The authors judged the evidence very low certainty (Liu et al., 2026). That last phrase is doing an ungodly amount of work. A statistically significant pooled effect is not a field-general force shield. And a meta-analysis cannot magically repair poor study quality just by inviting everyone into the same spreadsheet. There is another small but gigantic distinction: much of this research asks whether training in hypoxia improves subsequent repeated-sprint performance, often measured at sea level. Sunday's argument asks whether Minnesota's intermittent chamber strategy beats San Francisco's week-long stay when both teams perform at altitude. Those are different questions. Repeated-sprint adaptations and altitude acclimatization overlap, sure. They are not identical twins wearing matching purple jerseys. Hypoxic dose: your mitochondria do not accept punch cards Burtscher et al. (2022) reviewed hypoxic conditioning for pre-acclimatization. Short exposures may help in some circumstances, but more robust changes often involve upward of 60 total exposure hours. The paper discusses around 300 hours for extreme-altitude expedition preparation. Before anybody builds a 300-hour Vikings sleep bunker: that's mountaineering-level preparation, NOT an NFL-validated threshold for Mexico City. And the Vikings' 450 number is sessions across a roster, not 450 hours per human. Without duration, oxygen levels, intensity, frequency, and individual response, we cannot back-calculate an adaptation score. A tiny study with nine participants found lower heart rate and perceived exertion during a second simulated-altitude exercise bout at least 72 hours after the first, even at comparable oxygen saturation (Joyce et al., 2025). Interesting sign of improved tolerance? Absolutely. Evidence that a linebacker will suddenly acquire a fifth-quarter turbo button? Settle down. That work used hypobaric hypoxia, not an exact match for Minnesota's normobaric simulation, and nine people are not an NFL roster. I also suspect familiarity matters. If you have already experienced that obnoxious, high-ventilation "why does this feel harder?" sensation, it might be less psychologically threatening the next time. That's my hypothesis, not a demonstrated NFL chamber effect. Bonetti and Hopkins (2009), looking across 51 altitude studies, flagged the possible influence of placebo, nocebo, and training-camp effects. Translation: humans drag their brains into the altitude chamber, too. Belief, training changes, and the surrounding environment can muddy what we think is a clean oxygen experiment. The recovery bill arrives at 2 AM This is the angle I think the online experts are underpricing. Sleeping at altitude can be messy. Hypoxia increases ventilatory drive, and some people develop unstable breathing during sleep. Add travel, a new bed, changed routines, and the possibility of symptoms surfacing over the next 48--96 hours, and your carefully planned acclimatization camp can come with a side order of lousy recovery. Minnesota gets home beds, familiar food, regular practices, and (in theory) better-controlled sleep before flying in Saturday. San Francisco gets more time actually living at elevation. Which tradeoff is larger in these specific players? I cannot tell you from PubMed. Neither can the guy in the comments whose profile picture is a 2007 squat PR. Kyle Shanahan floated roughly a 2% edge for the Denver Broncos when opponents visit them, based on their elevation familiarity (San Francisco 49ers, 2026). I completely understand why a coach cares about 2% in an elite sport. But that's his estimate, not a measured difference between the Mexico City preparation protocols. And don't confuse home advantage with pure altitude physiology. An older NBA analysis suggested Denver and Utah had roughly 2.5 extra home wins per season, but that stew includes travel, scheduling, familiarity, crowd effects, opponents, and altitude (Petchesky, 2018). The 49ers are the designated home team in Mexico City and have a following there, but neither team is exactly rolling out of its usual locker room. The blinded study that should make every altitude Goo Roo sweat One of my favorite bits of this whole rabbit hole: Siebenmann et al. (2012) actually pulled off a double-blinded, placebo-controlled altitude study. Sixteen endurance athletes spent 16 hours a day for four weeks in rooms with either normal air or air simulating 3,000 meters. Questionnaires suggested participants could not reliably identify which condition they were in. Result? No improvement in hemoglobin mass, VO₂max, or 26-km time-trial power in either group. I can already hear the pitchforks scraping across the floor. That does NOT prove altitude training is useless. It tells us one specific live-high/train-low protocol under controlled conditions did not deliver those outcomes. Different doses and methods can behave differently. It's also not a double-blinded trial of NFL linemen arriving in Mexico City. Still, I love that somebody actually tested the belief machine instead of simply declaring victory over the atmosphere. My Vikings-biased verdict (with the receipts still attached) For actual acclimatization to living at elevation, I lean 49ers. More continuous time up there is a meaningful advantage in exposure. As for overall Sunday readiness? Much less clear. The Vikings may be less acclimatized, but better rested. Those ideas can coexist without the universe exploding. If I were advising the teams, I'd lean toward Minnesota's familiar-week strategy combined with the pre-exposure chamber work, especially for a single game. But I've been a Vikings fan long enough to admit that my purple bias has its own independent variable and a truly spectacular error bar. The Niners have their own reason to trust their approach. In 2022, they trained at elevation before playing in Mexico City and annihilated Arizona 38--10. Does that prove altitude preparation caused the blowout? Hell no. It proves the strategy coincided with a very good football game, which is enough to explain why a coaching staff might want to repeat it. Your practical lesson, whether you're flying to a mountain event, programming hypoxic training, or coaching someone who thinks an altitude mask turns them into a Himalayan yak: ask what the actual goal is. Are you trying to acclimatize to competing at altitude? Improve repeated-sprint ability later? Practice tolerating discomfort? Or preserve recovery before one important performance? Then look at exposure dose, timing, sleep, and what outcome the research actually measured. Those four questions will save you from approximately 93% of altitude-related Instagram nonsense. That number is from my extremely scientific eyeballometer. I dive much deeper into O₂ and CO₂ regulation, hypoxic and hyperoxic exposures, and when they are actually useful inside Pillar 4 of my Physiologic Flexibility Certification. That pillar literally took me 6 months to put together and I read over 100 studies just for that part alone. The cert opens again next year. If you want to learn the physiology instead of getting your credentials from the comments section, check out the Phys Flex Cert wait list HERE. For now I'm going to watch two very expensive applied-physiology experiments beat the crap out of each other on Sunday. SKOL!! May your phosphocreatine recover quickly, your oxygen saturation behave, and your defensive line remain gloriously unpleasant. Much love, violent consistency, and oxygen-pressure gradients, Dr Mike PS- If somebody tells you a 450-session team total guarantees that every Viking is fully acclimatized, ask for the individual exposure hours. Then ask whether they're talking about repeated-sprint training adaptations or actually competing in hypoxia. Those two questions will end more bar arguments than a bouncer named Thor. References Bonetti, D. L., & Hopkins, W. G. (2009). Sea-level exercise performance following adaptation to hypoxia: A meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 39(2), 107--127. Brocherie, F., Girard, O., Faiss, R., & Millet, G. P. (2017). Effects of repeated-sprint training in hypoxia on sea-level performance: A meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 47(8), 1651--1660. Burtscher, M., Millet, G. P., & Burtscher, J. (2022). Hypoxia conditioning for high-altitude pre-acclimatization. Journal of Science in Sport and Exercise, 4(4), 331--345. Han, M., & Liu, B. (2025). A multilevel meta-analysis of the effects of repeated sprint training in hypoxia on athletic performance. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 7, Article 1641379. Joyce, K. E., Byrd, M. T., Wheatley-Guy, C. M., Schwartz, J. C., Parks, J. K., & Johnson, B. D. (2025). Evidence for sustained physiological adaptation between consecutive exercise bouts at simulated altitude. Physiological Reports, 13(7), Article e70195. Liu, R., Wen, Z., Gou, P., Liu, S., Han, D., & Wang, J. (2026). Effects of repeated-sprint training in hypoxia on repeated-sprint and sprint performance in athletes: A systematic review and three-level meta-analysis. BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation. Advance online publication. Petchesky, B. (2018, September 7). Which teams in each sport have the biggest home-field advantage? Deadspin. Schuler, B., Thomsen, J. J., Gassmann, M., & Lundby, C. (2007). Timing the arrival at 2340 m altitude for aerobic performance. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 17(5), 588--594. Siebenmann, C., Robach, P., Jacobs, R. A., Rasmussen, P., Nordsborg, N., Diaz, V., Christ, A., Olsen, N. V., Maggiorini, M., & Lundby, C. (2012). 'Live high--train low' using normobaric hypoxia: A double-blinded, placebo-controlled study. Journal of Applied Physiology, 112(1), 106--117. San Francisco 49ers. (2026, November 18). Head coach Kyle Shanahan press conference [Transcript]. National Football League. (2026, November 19). Inside the Vikings' creative preparations for matchup with 49ers in Mexico City altitude. ________ Mike T Nelson CISSN, CSCS, MSME, PhD Mike T Nelson is a PhD and not a physician or registered dietitian. The contents of this email should not be taken as medical advice. It is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any health problem - nor is it intended to replace the advice of a physician. Always consult your physician or qualified health professional on any matters regarding your health. . |
Creator of the Flex Diet Cert & Phys Flex Cert, CSCS, CISSN, Assoc Professor, kiteboarder, lifter of odd objects, metal music lover. >>>>Sign up to my daily FREE Fitness Insider newsletter below
Hola from South Padre, TX, where your favorite nerd kiteboarded 47 miles yesterday over 3 glorious hours in moderately light winds, finishing as the sun disappeared into the Gulf. My legs are cooked, but it was awesome! Speaking of going the distance (cue Cake blasting in the background), today's lesson comes courtesy of the NFL, an old quarterback, scrambled eggs, and a spectacular case of professional chaos. You know I'm a massive Minnesota Vikings fan. Watching Kirko Chainz return from the...
Cardio, lifting, recovery, and the flaming circus of life after 40. How the hell do you juggle all of it without your gainZ going straight down the crapper? In this solo Ask Me Anything episode of the Flex Diet Podcast, I tackle seven listener questions about getting stronger without murdering your cardio, using HRV without bowing down to the almighty wrist computer, and why your progress has stalled harder than a rusted-out lawn mower subjected to the punishing salt water here in S. Padre...
Hola from South Padre Island, TX, where yesterday the wind was dead. Zero. Zilch. Nada. My kiteboarding dreamZ were flatter than a powerlifter's cardio program. …But Mother Nature compensated with a spectacular day and some rocket-fueled insanity. After a beautiful morning beach walk, some work, and a quick gym session, we hopped aboard a boat courtesy of our friend Captain Rob. The mission? Watch SpaceX launch a giant metal middle finger to gravity. And holy flaming ballZ. Watching that...